Music Teacher's Helper Blog

Observing the Student-Teacher Relationship

Have you ever noticed that you feel exhausted after teaching some of your students and exhilarated after others? With some, you’re catching yourself frequently glancing at the clock (which appears to have stopped) and with others you are constantly surprised that the lesson is over already?

I used to attribute this phenomenon to working with talented students versus the not so talented ones. While of course it can be more interesting to teach students who find picking up a musical instrument easy and make speedy progress, I’ve found that there are other factors to consider too, and they’re totally within your control.

One of the most striking realizations that I’ve had is that there is a correlation between how much effort I put into a lesson and how much effort the students make- and sometimes it’s an inverse correlation! As a young, inexperienced teacher, it was as if the harder I tried, the more I demonstrated, the more I spoke, the less my students did any of those things. As if there were only a certain amount of oxygen in the room and the deeper and faster I breathed, the less air remained for my student.

At one extreme, I remember lessons where I literally was left panting at the end of the hour, and the student appeared cool and unmoved. I began to realize that I needed to sit back in my seat, loosen my jaw, roll my shoulders, breathe deeply, speak less and give the students more space. As I began to become more aware of my energy and body language, it was quite an adjustment for my students, and me, and it was also the beginning of a wonderful journey of exploration for me, discovering what it really means to be a teacher.

As a result of gradual but substantial changes on my part, I began to notice other factors at work. When I sat back and gave eleven-year-old Rosie space at the piano, she shyly expressed an interest in composing her own pieces, and we took our lessons in a whole new direction. On the other hand, when I did the same with fourteen-year-old Natalie, she remained the taciturn, sulky teenager she had been all along, and it became clear that she would rather have been at home playing video games. She quit lessons shortly afterward, to our mutual relief.

One thing I’ve learned is that I don’t need to be an entertainer. If the child is really not interested in playing the piano, I’m very happy for them to take up electric guitar, horse-back riding or ballet.

A big discovery for me, as a young teacher, was that I needed to be more discerning about which students I accepted into my studio, not necessarily in terms of talent, but in terms of interest. I was keen to build my business, partly for financial reasons, and was therefore susceptible to the enthusiasm- and sometimes cajoling- of the parents who brought their students for lessons, “because I gave up the piano as a teenager and regretted it” or “because I never had the chance to play and always wanted to”. Worthy sentiments, but when their children were fidgeting miserably or blankly gazing around the room, I discovered that I was well advised to direct my questions to them personally, and ascertain whether they in fact were interested in learning the piano, or indeed music of any kind.

Now I if I discover that the child is showing no interest, I immediately encourage them to try another activity rather than piano lessons, and if the child is ambivalent, we set up a trial period of four to six lessons, “to see if we are compatible”, with no obligation on either side to continue after that period.

This system made me uncomfortable initially, as I had to become more assertive, and risk parents’ displeasure. However, 25 years on, I am delighted with the students in my current studio, all of whom practice diligently and energetically, focus enthusiastically during lessons, and perform with evident love of music and their instrument. After all, as one of my colleagues in London said to me, “I don’t want to have to convince anyone that music is beautiful.”

What have you learned from your relationship with your students? What sort of system, if any, do you use to vet students? I’d love to hear your comments.

About the Author

Valerie Kampmeier
Valerie Kampmeier, M.A., brings decades of performance experience as a successful classical pianist in Europe to her piano teaching and her life coaching practice for musicians. She also writes about living a creative life on her blog.
A gifted p... [Read more]

2 Comments

  1. Meg

    I love the comment of “I don’t want to have to convince anyone that music is beautiful.” I am a full time music teacher in an elementary school. I teach general music, vocal, and instrumental and absolutely love it. I also teach private flute and bassoon lessons. I was interested in your post because I have a few students in my private studio who play well, but have an attitude when I ask them to play a passage over again. Sometimes, lessons with these students are like pulling teeth. I am used to so many of my students who just love music, love learning, and love playing their instruments (perhaps that is because elementary students just “soak up” education and have such an excitement for school). Since I do not have a huge private studio, I do not want to lose anyone of my students and I certainly wouldn’t want them to quit playing. I have learned that with these students, I need to find what they enjoy and always throw their likes into lesson material. If they love to play Christmas Carols, I let them play the Christmas Carols for a lesson or two around the holiday, even if I feel they are not challenging enough. This seems to get rid of the attitude. You have to “keep the customer happy”, especially when you feel it is one battle that is just not worth fighting. I have seen so many gains with these students…perhaps, it is because they realize that I respect their desires, but will push and challenge them to be better…to like different styles of music…etc. I feel my greatest accomplishments are when the student who says…I hate duets and I’m not going to play them…..eventually, asks which duet book she should purchase and keeps me on my toes if I don’t end a lesson with a duet.

  2. Valerie Kampmeier

    Meg,
    I really understand what you are saying. I have also spent many an hour encouraging students who took some convincing. I acknowledge you, and so many other teachers, for all your hard work and dedication to your students. It’s a complex topic, and an ongoing conversation…

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.